Address
The Galleria 9626 N. Kings Hwy
Myrtle Beach, SC 29572
Research and insights contributed by Chris Kavanagh, Director of Instruction at Pinnacle Real Estate Academy
Here’s what happens in most buyer consultations: You ask what they’re looking for. They tell you their budget. Then they mention, almost as an afterthought, “We’re trying to save up 20% for the down payment.”
You nod. But here’s what you’re actually hearing: A buyer has already written their own story about what’s possible before you’ve even had a real conversation about financing.
That story is usually wrong.
One of the biggest disservices agents do to buyers is letting them operate under financial assumptions that limit their options. Buyers think they need to save 20% before they can buy. So they wait. They rent another year. They miss the market. Then when they finally have what they think they need, interest rates have shifted or inventory has dried up.
Meanwhile, they never learned that qualified buyers have access to programs that require far less. Some programs ask for 3%. Some ask for nothing at all depending on the loan type and buyer profile.
A real estate agent’s job isn’t to be a lender. But their job absolutely includes making sure buyers understand what’s actually available to them.
Most Buyers Are Limiting Themselves for the Wrong Reasons
The Data:
The National Association of Realtors tracks down payment trends every year, and the pattern is consistent. Buyers who’ve owned homes before put down significantly more than first-time buyers—often 20-25% compared to around 10% for first-timers.
Why the difference? It’s not because repeat buyers are naturally more cautious. It’s because they have something first-time buyers don’t: equity from their previous home.
This is something agents are already aware of, but worth breaking down again. When you own a home for several years, two things happen simultaneously. Your mortgage balance decreases every month as you make payments. At the same time, your home’s value appreciates. That gap between what you owe and what it’s worth is equity. The longer you own, the larger that gap becomes.
When repeat buyers sell, that equity converts into cash they can deploy toward their next purchase. That’s how someone who put down 10% on their first home ends up putting down 25% on their second.
But here’s a critical point: Just because equity exists doesn’t mean putting it all toward a larger down payment is the right choice. And just because a buyer doesn’t have equity doesn’t mean they should wait years to buy.
What Buyers Don’t Know (And What Agents Need to Tell Them)
The Financing Options Conversation:
Most buyers come to you with a predetermined ceiling on what they think is possible. “I need 20% down.” “I can’t qualify without 25%.” “I’ll need to save another two years.”
These aren’t facts. They’re assumptions, often based on outdated rules or anecdotal advice from someone who bought a home in a different market, under different circumstances.
The reality is messier and more empowering: There are multiple financing pathways available to qualified buyers, and each one changes the math on what’s affordable right now versus what requires waiting.
The agent’s role is to help buyers understand that these pathways exist before they lock into a decision about timing or how much house they can afford.
The Real Conversation: Down Payment Options
Scenario One: Repeat Buyers with Equity
A buyer owns their home in Myrtle Beach (for example). They bought it five years ago. They’ve built equity through two channels: monthly mortgage payments chipping away at the balance, plus property appreciation in a market that’s been strong.
They’re thinking: “I need to save for two more years before I can upgrade.”
What they don’t know: By selling their current home and accessing that equity now, they could potentially increase their down payment substantially—not in two years, but this month.
But here’s where it gets interesting. Just because they can put down 25% doesn’t mean they should. Maybe it makes more sense to put down 15%, keep more cash in their emergency fund, and deploy that extra capital elsewhere. Or maybe they should explore whether a 10% down payment paired with a specific loan product gives them monthly payment savings they didn’t expect.
Without running the actual numbers, they never know.
Scenario Two: First-Time Buyers
A first-time buyer thinks the down payment is their biggest barrier. They’ve been saving for three years to accumulate 15-20%. Meanwhile, they’re paying rent, watching the market move, waiting until they hit that magic number.
What they haven’t explored: FHA loans. Conventional loans with 5-10% down. VA loans if they qualify. USDA loans depending on location. Some programs offer down payments as low as 3-5% for qualified buyers.
The monthly payment difference between putting down 20% and putting down 5% matters. But it’s not always the deciding factor. Sometimes the real question is whether buying now at 5% down is smarter than renting for another year and buying at 15% down—especially if rates and prices have shifted.
Again, without running the actual numbers with a lender, the buyer defaults to a timeline that makes sense in their head, not a timeline based on actual financial reality.
What Changes When Buyers Understand Their Real Options
Lower Monthly Payments (Sometimes)
The conventional wisdom is simple: put more down, pay less monthly. That’s true mathematically—if you borrow less, your payment is smaller.
But it’s not always the best strategy. A buyer might discover that putting down 10% instead of 20% means a $150 higher monthly payment. That sounds bad. Until they realize keeping that extra $50,000 liquid in reserves gives them financial breathing room that’s worth far more than $150 a month.
Avoiding Unnecessary Costs
Private mortgage insurance (PMI) is a cost lenders add when buyers put down less than 20%. It protects the lender, not the buyer. But here’s what most buyers don’t know: PMI doesn’t stay forever. On many loans, once you hit 20% equity (through a combination of payments and appreciation), you can request to have PMI removed.
Some buyers wait years to save 20% to avoid PMI. Others put down 10%, accept the PMI for a few years while their home appreciates and they pay down principal, then request removal once they hit 20% equity. The PMI costs them $150/month for three years = $5,400. But they got into the home three years earlier, avoided rent for those three years, and benefited from appreciation during that time.
Without understanding this option, the default strategy is “save more, buy later.”
Stronger Negotiating Position
In a competitive market, sellers compare offers side-by-side. A larger down payment signals financial strength and reduces the seller’s risk that the deal won’t close. In a tight market, that confidence factor can be the difference between your buyer’s offer being accepted or passed over.
But that advantage exists whether it’s 15% down or 25% down. The buyer doesn’t necessarily need to max out their down payment to signal strength—they need to signal enough.
Where the Agent’s Role Becomes Critical
This is where agents step in.
Agents are not lenders. They don’t run credit reports or verify debt-to-income ratios. But they ARE the ones who have the initial conversation with buyers about what’s possible. They’re the people who can say, “Before we start looking, let’s make sure you understand your actual options. I want to connect you with a lender who can run real numbers on different scenarios.”
That conversation changes everything.
Instead of a buyer operating under a false ceiling, they’re operating with actual information. Instead of deciding “I can’t buy yet,” they’re deciding “I can buy now with a 10% down payment and here’s what that looks like monthly versus waiting two years and putting 20% down.”
Maybe waiting still makes sense. Maybe buying now is smarter. But at least the decision is based on facts, not assumptions.
The Three Conversations Agents Need to Have:
1. The Discovery Conversation:
“What down payment amount were you thinking?” Listen for the assumption. “And where did that number come from?” Often it’s “I heard you need 20%” or “That’s what my parents did.” Gently challenge it. “Let’s explore what options actually exist for your situation.”
2. The Lender Connection Conversation:
“Before we look at homes, I want to connect you with a lender who can show you the real numbers on different down payment scenarios. This way, you’ll know exactly what you can afford and what makes sense for your situation.” Frame it as a critical step to empowering the buyer.
3. The Follow-Up Conversation:
Once the lender has run the numbers, circle back. “What did you learn about your options? Does the monthly payment work for you? Do you want to adjust the down payment amount based on what they showed you?” Help the buyer integrate this new information into their decision-making.
These conversation don’t take long. But it transforms the buyer’s entire understanding of what’s possible. Suddenly, deals that seemed impossible become doable. Timelines that seemed locked become flexible. Buyers who were resigned to renting for another year discover they can buy this month.
That’s not just helpful, it’s the value of a real estate agent. Real Estate professionals do not just show homes, they open possibilities.
Interested in obtaining or upgrading your real estate license? Visit our website to explore your options today!
